The types of people who say “RRSPs are a Scam!”
When I see someone declaring that RRSPs are a scam and dig into their reasoning, I find they fall into a few categories. Here are my thoughts on each type. “I sell life insurance products whose investments are better than RRSPs. Look at this projection.” So far, I’ve found these projections like puzzles. How long will it take me to see the error? Do they leave out taxes? Do they add numbers decades apart without adjusting for inflation or investment returns? Somewhere in the columns of numbers there is a mistake or deliberate deception that makes the life insurance investment seem better than it is. This is the part of the RRSP-is-a-scam crowd that I have the least patience for. “Now that I’m 72, look at how much income tax I have to pay!” They’ve spent their adult lives enjoying tax refunds from RRSP contributions, but all that is forgotten now. For a million-dollar RRIF, the minimum withdrawal based on age 72 is $54,000. For those with o...