Posts

Showing posts with the label life insurance
Get new posts by email:
  

Permanent vs. Term Life Insurance

While I was on The Wealthy Barber podcast , David Chilton asked me whether I had analyzed cash value insurance.  Mainly, I’ve looked into projections from those selling cash-value life insurance.  They’re like puzzles to try to see where the mistake is.  Usually, they fail to take material cash flows into account, like ignoring tax on certain amounts, or they add dollar amounts from periods decades apart without taking into account inflation.  I haven’t looked at many of these projections, but the ones I’ve seen are flawed. Too much of the life insurance industry tries to confuse people into buying life insurance with premiums that are too high and coverage that is too low.  The truth is that almost everyone is best off with term life insurance with a death benefit large enough to properly protect their families. Here are the broad types of life insurance. Term life insurance Term life insurance is quite simple.  You pay a fixed premium for some period like...

<< Previous Post

When Does Permanent Life Insurance Make Sense?

The vast majority of people who need life insurance are best off with term life insurance. Salespeople have tried to sell me permanent life insurance (universal life and whole life), but I never got a good feel for when this type of insurance might make sense. Recently, the Rational Reminder podcast interviewed Glenn Cooke , an expert in insurance who communicates very clearly. Glenn’s explanations allowed me to understand when permanent life insurance may make sense. Before launching into my take on Glenn’s explanations, let me be clear that Glenn may not fully agree with me. In particular, he might find that the conditions I set out below are too narrow. Permanent life insurance only makes sense to me when all of the following conditions are met: You have maxed out both your RRSP room and your TFSA room. You definitely have more money than you’ll ever need, and you want to leave a legacy (which might include cash to pay off capital gains taxes on a property, such as a co...

<< Previous Post

Life Insurance: Permanent vs. Term

The internet is littered with debates over the merits of permanent life insurance and term life insurance. They both pay your beneficiary if you die. The main differences are that permanent life insurance costs more but has an investment component. Most debates are full of words, but the real answer to which is better is in the numbers. I looked at some numbers in an example from Gail Vaz-Oxlade and found her analysis to be seriously flawed. Brief description of term and permanent life insurance Term life insurance is fairly simple. You pay a monthly or yearly premium for 10 or 20 years, and if you die, your beneficiary gets the coverage amount. The size of the premium is based on the amount of coverage and how likely you are to die during the 10- or 20-year term. The younger and healthier you are, the less you pay. If you don’t die during the term, you have nothing to show for your premium payments. But, the premiums are lower than they are for permanent insurance. Perman...

<< Previous Post

Don’t Mix Life Insurance and Investments

The top bid in the Bloggers for Charity initiative was Glenn Cooke at InsureCan Inc. He donated $100 to the Wilmot Family Resource Centre that provides affordable social, educational, and recreational services and programs. What would you think if your car insurance broker suggested that you pay higher premiums for your car insurance in order to build up your RRSPs? You’d probably think that something was funny, and go looking for a real expert for your RRSPs. Conversely is your investment advisor the first person you call for advice on the best car insurance rates? Both of those situations smell a bit funny. Yet swap out the words ‘car insurance’ for ‘life insurance’ and all of a sudden many consumers find the idea more palatable. Why is that? The answer lies with a bit of history and a bit of insurance product design. Car insurance premiums are priced on a year by year basis – risk is passed along in the form of premiums each year. For most life insurance products,...

<< Previous Post

Not So Free Life Insurance

After a recent job change, I get new pay slips that contain cryptic entries about pay deductions. One of these entries is related to life insurance even though my employer gives me this insurance for free. Unfortunately, life insurance is considered a taxable benefit and I pay almost as much in income taxes as it would cost to buy the insurance on my own. For younger employees (like I was the last time I looked at this issue ), free life insurance can be more expensive than buying it on your own. In most group plans, life insurance premiums are based on the amount of insurance, but not the insured’s age. The plan assumes some average premium reflecting the age distribution of employees. This means that young people have an artificially high value assigned to their taxable life insurance benefit. Employees end up paying tax on this benefit at their marginal tax rates. For young employees, this can mean paying more for the insurance than it would cost them to purchase it privat...

<< Previous Post

Overpaying for “Free” Life Insurance

Many employers provide free life insurance to employees as part of their benefits package. Unfortunately for the employee, the premium paid by the company is a taxable benefit. In some cases the taxes owing can actually be more than what it would cost to buy the life insurance. I encountered this situation years ago when the tax rules changed making company-paid life insurance a taxable benefit. My company paid $1.68 per year for each $1000 of life insurance coverage. This amount had to be added to my income. At the prevailing marginal income tax rates, I paid taxes of $0.83 per $1000 of coverage. Perversely, I could buy life insurance cheaper than this. Although the cost wasn’t huge, I tried to decline the company life insurance on principle. A confused human resources person checked into it for me and came back saying that I couldn’t decline the insurance. At the time I tried to explain the situation to some colleagues, but it became obvious that few believed that what I ...

<< Previous Post

“Nothing is More Important than Family”

The title of this post is how an ad I received for life insurance starts. This line seems intended to exploit the fact that older people have a desire to leave money for their children and grandchildren when they die. This is an admirable goal, but the particular type of life insurance offered isn’t a good way for most of us to leave money for family. The ad goes on to explain that if you’re between 40 and 75 years old, “you cannot be turned down for any reason,” and “there’s no medical exam – and no health questions.” Wow! You’d think that everyone with a terminal illness would be lining up for this deal. The ad contains no hint of any kind of restrictions, but the web site of the bank offering this insurance has additional information. It turns out that if you die in the first two years, your estate doesn’t get the coverage amount. Instead, your estate gets an amount that is calculated based on how much you’ve paid in premiums. If you’re closer to the 75-year old end of the sca...

<< Previous Post

Life Insurance that Doesn’t Pay

How much are you willing to pay for life insurance that most likely won’t be paid if you die? Probably not much, if you know that your family won’t collect. I’ve always been suspicious of life insurance offered by employer benefits plans, and now I have a friend whose situation has confirmed my suspicions in at least one case. If you die suddenly in some way, there is no problem with life insurance from an employee benefit plan (apart from the fact that you’re dead!). The scenario that always worried me was what if I become terminally ill with cancer or some other horrible disease, and I’m unwilling or unable to continue working? Or maybe I develop a condition that prevents me from passing a physical to get life insurance, and then I get laid off. A friend of mine is in this last situation, laid off and unable to qualify for life insurance. Years ago, I asked about scenarios like this and was told by my employer that the life insurance is renewable. This means that employees ...

<< Previous Post

Life Insurance from my Alma Mater

Yet another mailing from the university I attended years ago arrived. It’s life insurance this time. In a burst of optimism, I think, maybe this will be a good deal because my alma mater will have trimmed the rates down as low as possible. I’ll get the benefits of a low cost group plan, and maybe university grads have slightly lower mortality rates. I decide to take a look. The first thing I see is a big picture of a smiling young woman. This is not a good sign. Advertisers know that men get looser with their money when they see smiling attractive women. I skip all the other mumbo jumbo and get right to the numbers. I’m a male non-smoker. I look up my age and desired coverage amount and find that the cost with the discount available to me is $67.50 per month. Is this good? I’m not sure. I could hunt through some paper files, but Google is right here at my fingertips. It took less than a minute online to get 12 quotes from the major insurers in Canada ranging from $46.40 to ...

<< Previous Post

Life insurance on Children

Another example of a bad deal is life insurance on children. In rare cases where a child actually has a substantial income that others depend on, it can make sense to take out life insurance on the child. But, in most cases, insuring a child’s life makes no sense; remember that the insurance offers no protection from death! I have had insurance agents try to talk me into insuring my children by arguing that I would need to cover funeral expenses, and that buying the insurance would guarantee future insurability. This was all nonsense. I can afford a funeral without the help of insurance, and if I couldn’t, I would choose something less costly than the standard funeral. The future insurability argument requires more explanation. When you buy term life insurance for, say, 10 years, it comes with or without the guaranteed right to renew the insurance at a particular price after the 10 years are up. If your insurance is renewable, then even if you develop a terminal illness in th...

<< Previous Post

Archive

Show more