Monday, July 6, 2009

UK to Eliminate Commissions to Investment Advisors

The UK Financial Services Authority plans to make big changes to the way that investment advisors are paid starting in 2012. They plan to make any fees charged to investors much more transparent. The blog Where Does All My Money Go reported the changes as so surprising that they seem like an April Fool’s joke.

Currently, investors as a group know little about how their advisors get paid. This is true in the UK as well as Canada and the U.S. In fact, many investors think that they don’t pay anything to their advisors.

The truth is that managers of financial products, such as mutual funds, offer commissions to advisors as an incentive to recommend their products. These commissions are paid from investors’ money, but most investors have little idea how much they are paying for their investment advice.

The changes coming in the UK promise to make the system much more transparent. Fees are to be negotiated between investors and advisors, and managers of financial products won’t be able to offer incentives to advisors. It will still be possible to have advisor fees paid out of invested funds, but the goal is to make investors aware of how much they are paying.

There is still plenty of time for the UK investment industry to fight these changes or water them down. We’ll have to wait and see how these changes get implemented.

Similar changes would be good for investors in Canada. Under the current system, an investor who invests $100,000 in mutual funds might pay a $5000 commission up front and $500 in trailers each year. Many investors would balk if they knew how much they were paying. Transparency of fees would lead to a huge shakeup in the investment advisor industry.


  1. Thanks for the mention - it would be a few years before we get a single national regulator and then a few years after that before anything like that happened here (best case scenario I think).

    The other part of the announcement which was long overdue, is the higher degree of training that will be required for advisors going forward. Amen to that as well...

  2. It has been a long time since I bought mutual funds, but seems to me it would be fair if investors had to sign an itemized list of fees. It's just too easy to ignore the prospectus.